Poll, Is Stock Trading A Game?

Posted by Blain Reinkensmeyer
September 10, 2007 at 11:35 am

I participated in the Carnival of Personal Finance this week, and kmull who hosted had a very interesting comment about my Extreme Trading post. It made me ask the question today, is stock trading really a game?

The comment left was, “The author argues that if you put in enough effort, you can ‘play the game and become rich.’ I disagree solely on the basis that investing is not a game to play. It is not betting.”

If stock trading is not a game, then what is it? When you invest in a stock, you are betting one way or another that a stock is going to move up or down. Am I really off on this one? Poll is below (RSS Readers you may have to click through to vote). Please share any comments as well, I am interested to hear your thoughts.



Related Posts:

4 Responses to "Poll, Is Stock Trading A Game?" »

Comment by Mikel
2007-09-10 11:46:17

Stock trading (unless you are doing soemthing illegal) it totally a “game”. It has rules, it has players. it punishes the losers and prizes the winners. sure you could say that given the right information it would never be a game, or a wager but really there is always the “chance” factor. Makes equity trading more like casino night than . . . .

 
Comment by My Trader's Journal
2007-09-10 14:51:41

Anything this fun has to be considered a game. I consider pro sports a game although it’s actually someone’s job. Just because it takes skill to consistently get it right doesn’t keep it from being a game.
As long as it’s not completely transparent (i.e. Enron) it still has an element of betting in it. Even if all companies told the truth all the time, what the Fed does could be considered a gamble on the stocks for how they will react to the unknown.

 
Comment by Kavit Haria
2007-09-10 17:47:55

Stock trading is a game. The safest way to play it is a game. Think about it like anything else and it’ll mess with your head. This way you appreciate what happens, learn from it and make another move. Pass go and collect 200. Stay out of Jail. Those are the rules as far as I see it Blain.

 
Comment by Mikel
2007-09-11 07:11:59

Looking back at my own portfolio and chances taken, my game looks more like high stakes keno than anything you’d call a business! hahahaha

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Subscribe to comments via email
mrgreen neutral arrow idea ? ! -) roll twisted evil cry oops razz mad lol cool ??? shock eek sad smile grin
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.
(Please Note: if this is your first comment, it will have to be approved before appearing publicly.)